“Contextualizing” Confederate Civil War Monuments — the Upcoming Challenge

Virginia Governor Ralph Northam signed two pieces of legislation this past weekend which will inevitably precipitate even more controversy over what to do with Confederate monuments.  One law gives authorities the power to decide to “remove, relocate, or contextualize” those monuments.  Another creates a commission to recommend a replacement for Robert E. Lee’s statue in Statuary Hall in the U.S. Capitol building.   The laws will reportedly go into effect on July 1.

Given the events of recent days, especially in Charlottesville, Virginia, I fear that those on the extremes of this issue will dominate the debate and the reaction to these new laws, with the potential for violence.  That’s why I very much hope the Civil war community will very strongly support the option of “contextualization.”  I fully realize that compromise and conciliation have not always fared well in this particular debate, but that doesn’t make it any less right or necessary.

I recently blogged here about the actions of the community in Franklin, Tennessee to contextualize the Battle of Franklin, November 30, 1864 as a worthwhile example to follow.   After many months of discussion and debate, the city placed several descriptive signs around the public square, which until recently had only seen a statue of a Confederate soldier.  The new signs describe, among other things, the formation of the U.S. Colored Troops and Reconstruction.  As a result, the context of the battle in the Franklin public square is more balanced and broad-based; no monuments were removed or replaced; and there was no violence because reasonable men and women found common ground.

Here are some images of the public square and two of the new signs.



Author: geneofva

Author of "Citizen-General: Jacob Dolson Cox and the Civil War Era," and of seven more Civil War books -- with more to come!!

One thought on ““Contextualizing” Confederate Civil War Monuments — the Upcoming Challenge”

  1. Thanks for your constructive recommendation on this hugely sensitive issue. I was struck in my 2017 visit to Ireland that the Dublin Castle did not remove the portraits of the British Governors. It is a recognition that as hateful as British rule was this was part of their history. As a free society you can’t obliterate the past — that may be well intentioned but it is Orwellian in the end. Find a constructive way to deal with the issue. Hugo


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: